The solution of an inequality in two variables is a region — and the sign does not tell you which side.
Same curve, same test point, opposite answers. Nothing but the substitution separates them.
One says greater and one says less, and it makes no difference at all — moving y across the sign is what flipped it. The sign depends on how the inequality happens to be written. The region does not.
Substitute. For y ≥ x² − 4:
| Point | Substitution | Where | Solution? |
|---|---|---|---|
| (0, 0) | 0 ≥ −4 | IN | yes |
| (2, 0) | 0 ≥ 0 | ON | yes — ≥ includes it |
| (1, −5) | −5 ≥ −3 | OUT | no |
ON is not a third region. It is the edge — and whether it counts depends only on whether the boundary is broken or solid.
Every one of these boundaries passes through (0, 0). Substituting the origin
gives 0 on both sides — a false statement, no warning, and a confidently shaded
wrong half.
If both sides come out 0, the origin is on the boundary. Pick another point.